Battle Over Prayer Continues in Galloway Township
A three-person committee will help determine how prayer will be presented in the township in the future.
Galloway Mayor Don Purdy has tasked a three-person committee with the job of helping to decide how prayer will be presented at council meetings moving forward. The committee, appointed Tuesday night, Nov. 27, will consist of Deputy Mayor Tony Coppola, Councilwoman Whitney Ullman and newly-elected councilman Jim McElwee.
The committee was designated in response to the recent outcry from Galloway residents over the decision to discontinue invocations prior to council meetings. In recent months, council has skipped the invocation and held only a moment of silence.
The issue came to the forefront at the council meeting on Nov. 13, and the township received a letter from the Anti-Defamation League on the issue prior to Tuesday’s meeting.
“Their suggestion was to have a council member do a prepared non-sectarian prayer or a moment of silence,” Township Manager Arch Liston said.
“I met with the county executive, and he said the county has a list of prayers done by freeholders on a rotating basis,” Purdy said. The prayer is agreed upon ahead of time. They’ve been doing this for years.”
Prior to Tom Bassford’s term as mayor, council meetings began with a non-denominational prayer led by a council member. On Tuesday night, Solicitor Mike Fitzgerald reiterated that particular practice is constitutional.
Democratic Club President Kevin Krumaker also pointed to the practice as a possible solution for the township following the Nov. 13 meeting.
I was happy to hear that the mayor and council appear to be leaning in the direction of my suggestion … regarding a return to a non denominational invocation that was practiced prior to the Bassford and (Keith) Hartman administrations,” Krumaker said Tuesday night.
Bassford introduced the idea of an invocation, and Hartman championed a policy of inviting every religious institution, regardless of belief, to give an invocation. If any religion was not represented by an institution in the township, Galloway would contact institutions at the county level in an effort to get a fair representation, according to Hartman.
On Tuesday night, pastors from some of those institutions commented during the public portion of the meeting, including Pastor Tom Douglass, of the Highland Community Church, who led a prayer for council during his comments.
“We need to welcome diversity and allow people to pray based on their convictions,” Douglass said. “Some of those invited haven’t come and prayed, and some of us have come here more often. So what? I encourage you to search your heart and find the best way to show diversity and welcome the community.”
“I love Galloway, and I continue to pray for each of you,” Pastor Al Syvertsen of the Beacon Evangelical Free Church told council. “At this time, Galloway is in need of prayer. Prayer is important.”
The township has maintained that pastors didn't abide by guidelines set forth to keep invocations non-sectarian, leading to the end of the policy. However, the pastors in attendance Tuesday night claimed they stuck by what they were asked to do when they appeared before council.
“I feel there was behind the scenes manipulation,” Pastor Dean Bult of Mainland Baptist Church said. “I feel a great injustice has been made for the state to say they can’t take a couple of minutes for a prayer.”
Bult isn’t the only person to state he believed there was more at work behind the scenes. Resident Anna Jezycki brought with her a set of closed session minutes from a previous council discussion of the issue, stating that if she chose to read them out loud, it would cause a lot of problems.
“When this policy was implemented, there was no argument and nothing was said about it,” Jezycki said. “The resolution says prayers are permissible. Why is this a big issue? Because someone was offended. Well (the residents) are offended and they are more than one person.”
Jezycki was referring to Councilwoman Whitney Ullman. Ullman was named by resident Tom Mitchell at the Nov. 13 meeting, and she was appointed to the committee on Tuesday night.
Initially, Councilman Brian Tyrrell was appointed, but Coppola suggested Ullman should be nominated. She ended up replacing Tyrrell.
“We’re going to come up with a fair solution and be respectful of everyone’s rights and religious beliefs,” Ullman said. “We need to protect the township from unnecessary litigation. We also need to be thankful for all that we have, and that we have loved ones to go home to.”
Ullman said that while all members of council agreed the resolution passed during Hartman’s administration, they saw that it was not working. She said all council members had input when discussing the issue.
“We have a responsibility to protect the taxpayers,” McElwee said. “We have to protect their money and their property taxes. We’re trying to come up with a compromise, but it’s a tricky balance.”
“The primary purpose of government is to protect the people, not only personally, but financially as well,” Krumaker said. “Jim McElwee reinforced this ideal by explaining that reinstituting the non-denominational prayer led by a council member is the best way to protect the taxpayers from any further lawsuits.
“The policy of having a council member lead the prayer should have never been changed. Why fix what was not broken?”
While other residents, including a disabled Vietnam War veteran, were in support of keeping invocations, others were not completely on board. One resident described the discussion as “bullying,” those with different religious beliefs, while another posed a simple question: “If Jesus comes back tomorrow, will you be safe?”
In addition to returning to a non-denominational prayer or continuing with a moment of silence, Fitzgerald said any pastor who wished to lead a prayer during the public comment portion of meetings would be protected by the First Amendment. He also said a brief public comment portion could be held at the beginning of the meeting, for any pastor who wishes to say a prayer before government begins to conduct its business.
Dofang
7:10 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
The best way to kill religion is to integrate it with the state.
Karen Jones
7:13 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Come on Galloway and WORLD! A basic prayer of please give us strength and guidence for our state, town and city. Protect all that serve. AMEN! If someone does not want to be included in prayer then then can enter meeting late. or say their own to themselves. What is this world comming to. We need to all take responsibility and make the difference lots of things are changing in this world and towns and not for the good, its not bad to ask for a little help!
Sue Kingsley
7:44 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
AMEN! That's what council wanted, a generic prayer for guidance etc., but according to the article Clergy didn't follow the rules. It is a shame that they had to ruin it for everyone.
Sue Kingsley
7:36 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
The passion of the community is commendable, but it seemed as though the pastors and some residents lost focus of the problem at hand. If you were at the meeting, this ideal of a separation of church and state spoke for itself, it was like sitting in a church service for hours. Some Pastors gave a prayer ending in Jesus name, one woman talked about being saved by Jesus etc. These people just don't get it. We aren't in Church! They were focusing on how council was disrespecting them, but in reality they were not being sensitive and respectful to others. That's why, as explained clearly buy mayor, council and legal that they need to come up with something to protect their town not just in litigation but also as mostly everyone said, all religious faiths. They keep intertwining Jesus and God and that's the problem. When clergy gave prayer, they were all really good until the ending. If they would just end with something inclusive of all then there wouldn't be a problem. The one girl stood up for it at the meeting and she was right. It is almost as if people are bullying to get their religious beliefs out there. Although probably not intentional but they are disrespecting others by forcing their beliefs and then telling the others that they are disrespecting them. Whatever the case, we need to all come together as American's and love one another no matter what religion, race, sex etc. God Bless America!
Dofang
7:50 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Matthew 6:5-8:
And whenever you pray, do not be like the hypocrites; for they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and at the street corners, so that they may be seen by others. Truly I tell you, they have received their reward.
But whenever you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you.
When you are praying, do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do; for they think that they will be heard because of their many words. Do not be like them, for your Father knows what you need before you ask him.
Jo Mongiello
8:19 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
It is a sad commentary when prayer is the subject of division and controversy. Why can we not have a prayer thanking God for all we have. Too many people constanly complain about what they want and do not have instead of appreciating all the blessings that God has given us.
Jo Mongiello
Dofang
8:50 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Because the council represents everyone in this town, not just Christians, and not just people who believe in God. It's one thing to pray privately; it's a whole different story when the government gets involved.
Red
11:15 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
The problem is that the people pushing for the prayer at Council are ignoring the fact that the government and anyone speaking for the government or with the endorsement of the government should NOT be doing a prayer. The pastors should never have been invited to do prayers -- it was fine the way it was before Bassford and his idiotic comment years ago that "Galloway is a Christian community" -- no we aren't a Christian community -- we are a diverse community and as a result any prayer should be non-denominational and should be done by one of the Council members.
The bottomline is that the Council has one job -- promote and protect the fiscal wellbeing of the township -- they are not in place to provide a moment of prayer for the township residents.
If people want prayer -- sit down in your own home and pray -- God's ears are open 24/7 -- it's only the people who want to advertise their religion and their religious faith who have to take it to the public square for everyone to see it and hear it.
Stan Walker
8:33 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Instead of complaining about prayer I wish more people would complain when someone in the peanut gallery raises a nonsensical issue. I would favor a Gong Show format where the panel gives someone the gong when they blabber on about some goofy issue.
Dofang
8:50 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
That would certainly increase attendance at council meetings. Love it.
Samantha Siang
8:40 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
There is no controversy; the government of Galloway Township needs to follow the established fact of separation of church and state! Why is this so difficult? Perhaps
these so-called citizens never heard of the constitution, among other things. It's a government function, not a religious gathering for pete's sake! Get real Galloway.
marlene Obrien
11:06 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Prayer doesn't hurt, prayer gives love and understanding n strength to try make the right decision life for everyone. Why do have to take it to different level, America was founded under god by our forth fathers. So doesn't have to b Christian, muslin, n so on everybody in one way or another believes there is a god. So pray out lound or pray in silent, just pray please .
ChuckV
8:07 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
It does hurt because you are using government meetings to tell other people they are wrong. You are always free to have your own private prayer. There are citizens who don't believe in any god and we shouldn't have to listen to your religion to attend government meetings.
The US government was not founded under any god. The US Constitution clearly states who ordained and established the Constitution.It was "We the People", not Jesus or any other god. Via the first amendment, government is barred from establishing any religion and the Treaty of Tripoli clearly states "Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion".
Dofang
11:26 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
@ Marlene, Personally, I don't believe in any God or gods, and know plenty of people in Galloway who don't. But we are decent American citizens who see these things as attempts to exclude. Nobody's stopping private prayer here, just trying to make sure our government remains neutral on theological matters.
Tadiddy5
2:08 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
This is funny. This discussion started because one person was 'offended'. You know whats really offensive? Living in a town that's the laughing stock of South Jersey, living in a town that is going to be saddled with the results of multi-million dollar lawsuits the township is sure to loose, living in a town that is again reducing its police force, living in a town where public services are non-existent, living in a town that has to give every single municipal employee a layoff notice. Those are things I find personally offensive. Maybe this was the 'wit'less wonder's way of distracting the public from the total disaster that this council has made of Galloway. Here's an idea, stop worrying about stuff that really doesn't matter and fix the real problems this town has. Personally I could care less if a prayer is said before a meeting or not. I understand the separation of church and state, it is good to keep those things apart, to many people with to many different opinions, which leads to nothing ever being accomplished. Galloway has real problems, and our local braintrust has decided this is one they need to have a committee decide on what to do next. For this to be an item anyone has to waste their time on shows that the only thing Ms. Ullman is doing is wasting space up on the dais. How about you seven mental midgets actually try and do some good for the residents that elected you instead of further pushing your own agendas.
Stan Walker
7:09 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Exactly! We have much bigger fish to fry than this.
Pierre Reid
2:13 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
John 14:6
Jesus said, ' I am the way, the truth and the life; no one comes to the father but by me. The "no one", He referred to includes Jews and Gentiles. Jews are not saved because they are God's chosen people, but because they beleive in Jesus Christ as their Messianic. Jews who have accepted Yeshua ( The hebrew word for "JESUS" as their Messiah.
This removable of prayer has been written, these days would come. This action does not alarm us but strengthens and confirms God's word. We will continue to pray for those who are placed in government postions. They are todays phararisees and sadducees. Everyone has a voice, but the best sounds are those coming from a humble heart, which can't be silence for even a momment.
58yearGresident
8:12 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Are we really back to this again. How about "Suffer the Little Children" or don't they and their Families count since some of the Galloway Employees an those Lost in the last 3-4 years whom have lost their Jobs and for those who will in 30 Days. I guess they don't need bread on their Tables, or clothes on their Backs. But all you who are worrying about Prayer in a Council Meeting, just keep worrying about prayer while you sleep warm and open lots of unnecessary presents and pretend to care about your fellow man. We put our trust and livelyhood in the hands of your Beloved "wasn't he a Deacon?", Steve bonani, whom caused Permanant Damage to many Ex-Employees and obviously "Lots of Children". I bet you still Pray for Bonani, sleep on That!
VTPat
12:13 pm on Sunday, December 2, 2012
Wow, see what I mean about Christian bigots? Humble heart? Alot of nonsense spewed but the venom is obvious. You Pierre are why I left the church. All Jews go to hell? I am sorry sir but you are wrong.
Libra Belle
2:16 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
We all just went through a major natural catastrophe, some were not at fortunate than others. We are all trying to pick up the pieces and rebuild our homes and lives. A 30 BILLION dollar cleanup and restoration of our Jersey shores. So when at our local township council meeting, you would think we would discuss our progress and township ordinances. NO! people are focusing on an issue about an invocation prayer and how they are offended for not saying particular religious references with in that prayer. This was and always should be a non-denominational saying of good faith before a PUBLIC meeting. Despite your religious beliefs, this is a government regulated agency not an institution of prayer and religious practices! Come on, this took up the meeting minutes when there is so much havoc on our community and current pressing issues. Let council do their job and stop wasting taxpayers time because 3 people want their preferred religious orator to commence a prayer that focuses on their personal faith.
Dofang
2:28 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Exactly. We should be banding together after the hurricane, not turning ourselves into a laughingstock.
Keep Galloway Green
9:06 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Here's a little history..."It cannot be emphasized too strongly or too often that this great nation was founded not by religionists but by Christians, not on religions but on the Gospel of Jesus Christ"....Patrick Henry 1765
Dofang
9:40 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
That would've been news to Jefferson and Madison, who managed to never mention Jesus in the Declaration or the Constitution. You'd think an explicitly Christian Constitution would've mentioned Him once or twice, no?
Dofang
9:43 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Oh, and I challenge you to specify the source of that Patrick Henry quote. It doesn't occur in any of his writings. (See Snopes; http://www.snopes.com/politics/religion/capital.asp)
Keep Galloway Green
9:31 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
I found that quote on Goodreads.com....Here is another by Patrick Henry..."Let us trust in God and better judgement to set us right hereafter. United we stand, divided we fall. Let us not split into factions which must destroy that union upon which our existence hangs"
Dofang
2:11 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Don't remember Patrick Henry being a drafter of the Constitution. You might be familiar with John Adams, who stated in the Treaty of Tripoli: "As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion."
If one had to pick a single philosophical underpinning for our government, I'd put my money on the Enlightenment instead.
Again, I restate: if the Founders had intended a Christian Constitution, they would have stated so explicitly. These guys knew how to write clearly.
nancy
5:16 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
really. keep your christian values to yourself.
Sean Conneamhe
10:17 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
"The Lenape people have been here for thousands of years with their own non-Christian spiritual tradition."
Susieq
11:26 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Interesting how when something bad happens people either turn to a vice or God.
9/11 as an example
Why is it so hard to have a prayer when people say for "Gods sake" or "Jesus Christ" as swear words?
Galloway can sure use prayer and so can other towns. If it is said before the meeting I do not see any harm done. I realize their should be a separation of church and state but this is not a state meeting people! It is simply a TOWN meeting.
Dofang
7:11 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
0_o "State" means "government." Town government has to follow the Constitution.
58yearGresident
8:20 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Are we really back to this again. How about "Suffer the Little Children" or don't they and their Families count since some of the Galloway Employees an those Lost in the last 3-4 years whom have lost their Jobs and for those who will in 30 Days. I guess they don't need bread on their Tables, or clothes on their Backs. But all you who are worrying about Prayer in a Council Meeting, just keep worrying about prayer while you sleep warm and open lots of unnecessary presents and pretend to care about your fellow man. We put our trust and livelyhood in the hands of your Beloved "wasn't he a Deacon?", Steve bonani, whom caused Permanant Damage to many Ex-Employees and obviously "Lots of Children". I bet you still Pray for Bonani, sleep on That!
VTPat
12:09 pm on Sunday, December 2, 2012
Like Dave below says, a distraction. They know that Christian bigots never pass up an opportunity to attempt to impose their will on others. That way they can have "heaven on earth" in many cases in the form of material wealth. In the case of Galloway that has been at the expense of taxpayers. Do you really believe that given the power that Evangelicals seek, a religious state, that they would be God-like in their imposition of say...Canon Law?
David Morlando
8:23 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Wake up fellow citizens! This is another red herring tossed about by the republican led council. The real issues are a budgetary crisis, lay-offs of critical personel and a proposed one million dollar revaluation of properties that in no way guarantees to stop the flood of property tax appeals. Our council needs to spend less time on praying (doing and talking about it) and more time on fixing our fiscal mess.
Keep Galloway Green
8:52 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
More history...."We recognize No Sovereign but God, and no King but Jesus!....John Adams...John Hancock - April 18, 1775.
Dofang
2:13 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Citation please? I smell another fake here.
Dofang
3:28 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Found evidence this was a fake quote as well. While I appreciate your desire to 'Keep Galloway Green,' I'm not sure the best way is to recycle bogus quotes.
Keep Galloway Green
8:12 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Since I wasn't there in 1775 I can't make the judgement whether the quotes are real or fake. Were you there?....
Dofang
8:22 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Love it: make stuff up and then say "were you there?" Were you there when Jesus was born?
VTPat
11:51 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
how about the fact that many of them were Masons, do some research on that. What "God" did they worship? The Christian God? I think not...
Stan Walker
12:51 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Don't worry, folks. Sharia law is on its way.
Dofang
2:12 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Or at least the Christian version.
nancy
5:13 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
oh for gods sake" excuse the expression". is this what council needs to be talking about?.get off the prayer,have a moment of silence and get on to the real issues!!!
Keep Galloway Green
8:21 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Try this Quote on for size....lol....From the Office of the Chaplain , United States House of Representatives ...First Prayer of the Continental Congress 1774 - (Last line) "All this we ask in the name and through the merits of Jesus Christ , Thy Son and our Savior. Amen ....Reverend Jacob Duche - Rector of Christ Church of Philadelphia , Pennsylvania Sept 7, 1774 9AM. (Office of Chaplain Phone # 202 225- 2509)
Dofang
8:25 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
And that proves... that there were Christians in the 18th century.... Show me the quote in the Constitution citing that this is a Christian Nation. That would have been quite easy to write.
Keep Galloway Green
8:29 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
I didn't make up any of those quotes...I got them off different websites. So by you saying I made those quotes up...your actually making up a fake story about me. Get it?....
Dofang
8:31 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
If you want to draw a fine line between sloppy research and making things up.
Keep Galloway Green
9:58 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Some people say landing on the Moon was fake....Who's right?.....Show me your neat research where there is no mention of God by the Founding Fathers.
Dofang
10:41 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
... in the Constitution.
Keep Galloway Green
11:19 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
"In God We Trust"....has the government ever printed that phrase & put it on say money?....lol
Dofang
7:03 am on Friday, November 30, 2012
Right. And the dollar bill supersedes the Constitution.
Keep Galloway Green
11:30 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
ANNUIT COEPTIS
Sean Conneamhe
6:46 pm on Friday, November 30, 2012
"An invocation should be made to Michi Manitou, the Great Spirit of the Lenape People who have lived in Absegami (Galloway Township) for 12,000 years, way before the European invasion and occupation."
VTPat
11:48 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
What I noticed more than anything else was the hypocrisy of many of those calling themselves "Christians." They speak of tolerance then in the next breath warn of imminent condemnation of those who do not accept Jesus as their savior. They want to hang their halos on "tolerance" yet have no tolerance for others that do not believe as they do. I believe in Jesus but not the dogma of those who claim to speak in his name. I have some bible quotes of my own but christian bigots and their "men of the cloth" would only dismiss me and condemn me. Thank God the Mayor is at least a sensible person.
VTPat
11:58 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
BTW I could care less what God anyone invokes or believes in. My problem is, has been, and always will be, bigots, liars and thieves hiding in the church and using it to promote their own childish self righteous nonsense. You better hope that no religion gets a foot up on imposing their dogma, you all know the history there. Mankind has not matured to the point where we yet tolerate others beliefs when the majority are in control and have the power to oppress. Do some research on that issue and you will understand what separation of church and state is. The evangelicals and Bible thumpers on this blog know nothing except emotional hysteria and dogma.