patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

New Law Allows Schools to Pass Budgets Without Voter Approval, Move Elections to November

The Galloway School Board will discuss this issue at a future meeting. The next meeting takes place Monday.

 

School districts now have the authority to move school board elections from April to November, and can now pass a school budget without voter approval under new legislation signed into law by Gov. Chris Christie on Tuesday.

The budget can be passed without voter approval as long as it stays within the 2-percent tax cap established for school boards and municipalities last year.

The law states that there are three ways the election can be moved and the school budget taken out of the hands of the voters:

  • by referendum, similar to the two placed before the voters by the Galloway Township and the Greater Egg Harbor Regional school districts in December;
  • a resolution set forth by the board of education; or
  • a resolution set forth by township council.

“Since it is such an important issue, the Board of Education members need to carefully consider all aspects of holding the elections in November,” Galloway Superintendent of Schools Annette Giaquinto said on Wednesday. “The Board of Education will be discussing this at an upcoming meeting.”

The Board of Education’s next scheduled meeting is Monday night, Jan. 23 at the middle school, and Giaquinto confirmed late Thursday afternoon that this issue will be discussed.

The Greater Egg Harbor Regional School District, made up of Absegami High School, Cedar Creek and Oakcrest, also meets Monday night.

The Galloway School District saw two budgets defeated during the 2011 calendar year.

In April, the school budget was defeated by a vote of 902-875 in an election in which 1,803 people voted. Township council later cut $362,578 out of the proposed $53 million budget before passing it.

In December’s special election, voters defeated a proposal concerning roof replacement at Smithville, Arthur Rann and Roland Rogers elementary schools, fire alarm replacement for Smithville, Roland Rogers and Reeds Road, and drainage system and parking lot improvements for Arthur Rann. On election night, the proposal appeared to be defeated by just three votes, and after provisional ballots were counted, the difference was eight votes.

Galloway voters also defeated the Greater Egg proposal on the same night, but that proposal partially passed because of voters in the other areas that make up the regional district.

At its last meeting, the Galloway school board considered going back to referendum in March, and board member Bob Iannacone pointed out the district can go straight to the state for approval. This occurred during a situation similar to what Galloway is facing in Allentown in 1979, but the board decided it wanted to put it back into the hands of the public.

While Galloway felt the need to put the decision back in the hands of the voters, the New Jersey School Boards Association (NJSBA) understands why school districts are wary of allowing the public to decide its budget.

"Voters do not get to vote on municipal or county budgets,” NJSBA spokesman Frank Belluscio said. “School budgets often bear the brunt of voter dissatisfaction."

NJSBA is fine with removing voter approval from school budgets, provided the budgets stay within the state-mandated cap.

"Budgets undergo review at several levels and the state Department of Education has redline authority,” Belluscio said. “Voter interests are represented through the process already."

New Jersey Education Association Spokesman Steve Baker echoed Bellusico’s comments.

“Nowhere else do voters get a direct say in the budget by voting for it,” Baker said. “School boards set the budget based on their individual community and school needs—that's what they're elected to do and that's what they should be doing."

Then there’s the issue of elections for school board members. If moved to November, the elections would coincide with municipal elections, and this year, the presidential election.

In each of the last two years, the Galloway School District has spent approximately $17,000 to stage an election in April, according to Galloway Township School District Business Administrator Tim Kelley.

According to Kelley, none of the last four elections has seen a turnout of more than 4,000 in a township made up of approximately 37,000 people. In three of those elections, less than 2,000 came out to vote.

If a school board decides to move its election to November, any board member whose term would’ve expired in April will get to stay on the board until December, an additional eight months.

Three seats will be decided in this year's election, as Richard Dase, Bob Iannacone and Eileen Kasunich are all up for re-election. Kasunich was a board member previously, but chose not to run in last year's elections. She returned to the board following the resignation of Kathy Styles-Landgraf in June.

No deadline has been set by the state to make the change at this time, but if a district is uncertain about what it wants to do at this time, it won’t have to make its final decision. They can make the change at any point in the future by adopting a resolution at a public hearing. The township can also make that determination and it can also be changed by voter petition.

Also, the Galloway and Greater Egg Harbor Regional districts don’t have to agree on an election month. It is possible one group may decide to make the change while the other remains the same.

Camden County Patch Assistant Regional Editor Lauren Burgoon and Moorestown Patch Local Editor Rob Scott provided some information for this story.

  • What do you think of the possibility of moving school board elections to November?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Let's do it: it'll save some money.
        37 (82%)
    • I don't like that school board members who are up this year could serve beyond their designated term.
        5 (11%)
    • I don't like it for another reason (tell us in the comments.)
        2 (4%)
    • Not sure
        1 (2%)
    Total votes: 45
  • Does the possibility that a school budget could pass without voter approval bother you?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes
        34 (69%)
    • No
        13 (26%)
    • Not sure
        2 (4%)
    Total votes: 49
  • This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Absegami High School and Galloway Township Schools

Barbara London Waringer

12:24 am on Friday, January 20, 2012

The problem in Galloway is getting people who qualify to vote to the polls. Moving to November would guarantee a bigger turnout, but not necessarily in a positive way for the schools. I would first pass a resolution to research the matter and leave the possibility of change open, not rush into it especially in a Presidential election year. In the meantime, if possible, send out a questionaire to parents of students to ask why they did or did not vote in the last budget election. Done anonymously, you might find out that many are unable to vote as they are not registered or qualify to be registered.
I definitely feel though the budget should be taken out of voters' hands as many do not fully comprehend the whys and wherefors, they just vote no if there is any increase, minimal or otherwise. The education of our children should be the MOST important responsibility of any community. The future of the community and ultimately the US depend upon quality educational opportunities for every child.

Reply

Stan Walker

6:49 am on Friday, January 20, 2012

Throwing an endless supply of money at education does not produce quality education. The future of the community and the US is in danger because our current education model fails to teach our students fiscal responsibility with its ever increasing budget requests. Christie's two percent cap has been nothing more than an irresponsible license to continue to simply keep increasing taxes and spending.

Reply

Diogenes

10:47 pm on Friday, January 20, 2012

I would caution that before you think that money is simply being thrown at education willy-nilly, analyze the components that go into the school budget. Schools can't control huge increases that health insurance companies throw at them. Costs for supplies, textbooks, technology equipment, and buildings that are in need of repair contribute to increases in the school budget just as much as other factors such as salaries. So before we make a general statement that money doesn't produce a quality education, we must know the factors that go into a school budget. In today's world, education is hardly getting an endless supply of money because of all the cutbacks at the state level and the difficulty getting budgets passed at the local level. I have actually even seen budgets defeated that resulted in lower taxes than previous years.

Reply

Bill

7:51 am on Sunday, January 22, 2012

As with all budgets therre is waste. The problem I have is when the school board approves cutting programs and cutting teachers and in the same meeting approving a $40,000 raise for the superintendent. And then boasting they are doing away with an asst. Superintendent saving us $130,000/ year. So with 2 high schools we need a super and an asst and now with 3 high schools one can handle it all? So the way I see it for the past 20 years we unnecessarily spent $130,000/ year. So when I see signs stating, Vote for Our Children's Future, then see their programs cut and hefty raises given out, what am i actually voting for?

Reply

buck

4:10 pm on Monday, January 23, 2012

what bothers me is . the loss of the right to vote on how our labor{money} is spent .
one more right gone - more to follow . this is a very bad trend . only the " qualify " people who understand the correct way can make the" right decision "
this is the rational that is used take the rights from the people .

Reply

Barbara London Waringer

5:11 pm on Monday, January 23, 2012

in reply to buck....what you described is exactly how our democratic government works. We the people go to the polls and vote for representatives of Congress/Senate. They in turn vote for us on the national budget. We the people do not directly vote on a budget that is made up in part by our tax dollars. The right to vote for the representative that will then vote on the school budget is not being taken away.

Reply

Leave a comment